The Same Mark, Two Different Instructions
Symbol stands for a color
Symbol stands for a shade
Both are symbol coloring pages, and a page never tells you which kind it is — the legend does. Read it before the first cell, not after.
What Is Color by Symbol? A Beginner's Guide
On a symbol page the code is a shape rather than a digit — and that shape can mean a color or a shade. The legend is the only thing that tells you which.